

"We have some refugees in our school. I think they're the only two. And people get really annoyed with them and that. So like everyone's like taking the mickey out of them and just doesn't like them. So, we like, most people just walk round getting on their nerves and bullying them".
Q: - How does this project help to change people's opinions?
A: - "Because at least we can recognise what they've been through, and why they might have moved out of their country to come and live over here, or in a different country".
Pupil from Marlowe Academy Ramsgate involved in Music for Change and Migrant Helpline 'Safe and Sound' project.
With reference to refugee and asylum seeker issues, a 2007 report by the DfES declared that 'every child needs an education that is contextualized and relevant to them. Dialogue about who they are in relation to society and what it means to be a citizen should be at the heart of this. How else will pupils be able to take on some of the difficult and controversial issues that are increasingly likely to confront them?' (Dfes, Ajegbo, Kiwan and Sharma, 2007: 19).
The Pledge project has been designed by cultural organization Music for Change to support those working with young people to deliver this section of the curriculum.
The Pledge project seeks to facilitate critical thinking and reflection about student opinion of refugees, asylum seekers and migrants through the use of creative learning techniques, music and visual and performed arts. Pledge is designed to give students the facts and information that they need to be able to make up their own minds about these emotive issues and control the creative direction of the project.
Through projects such as Pledge, Music for Change aims to support schools in mainly white areas that are facing change in the cultural make-up of their communities through inward migration from refugees, asylum seekers and EU migrant workers. This change is inevitable, and this project is dedicated to preparing young people for the world in which they will be living. By taking part, students will be encouraged to see the world differently, to accept the change and to value diversity. The project will provide them with accurate information to help them to form their own opinions-opinions that are based on fact, not fiction. By learning to accept difference and cultural diversity, students will be able to think about newly arrived communities as people rather than as a problem.
The purpose of this web report is to highlight the need for adequate provision of education about these issues, supporting the DfES's vision that 'in five years all schools [will] be actively engaged in nurturing in pupils the skills to participate in an active and inclusive democracy, appreciating and understanding difference'.
This web report is also designed to equip those working with young people with knowledge, ideas and resources to enable them to raise awareness of diversity and citizenship and to cultivate an understanding in young people of the issues of asylum seekers and refugees, preparing them to positively contribute to Britain's increasingly multi cultural society.
On this website we include documentation of the 2009/10 Music for Change Pledge project, delivered in conjunction with Shepway Find Your Talent, both as an example of best practise and to highlight the importance of a multi-agency approach in the endeavour to educate today's young people in diversity and citizenship.
'Asylum seekers are associated with illegality and deviance and are perceived to be economically motivated' (Finney, 2005).
The above summarization of the British publics' opinion was concluded from the findings of a number of surveys and studies on public opinion about asylum seeker and refugee issues in the UK.
Since the mid-1990s international migration to the UK has increased due to asylum arrivals, sustained work permits and other work visa flows and large scale migration from the new European Union member states since 2004. In Kent alone 12,600 migrants entered in 2006-2007 (Kent County Council, 2007).
Despite the steady influx of asylum seekers and refugees to the UK, research shows that there is still 'considerable confusion, ignorance and misinformation about asylum issues. People in general have poor knowledge about asylum and immigration issues and there is a problem of information provision' (Finney, 2005).
The negative attitudes held by a proportion of the British public are reflected in some of the statistics from the most recent British Crime Survey (BCS):
There is an estimated 50 million refugees worldwide, and although Britain only hosts
3 % of these, a recent MORI (Market & Opinion Research International) poll showed that the British public believes that we host 23%. Furthermore, the DfES states that 'the notion of racial hierarchies has not altogether disappeared and stereotypes still abound in society' (Ajegbo, Kiwan and Sharma, 2007: 6).
Furthermore, it has been found that young peoples' opinions are more likely to be negative and misinformed than adults: 'young people with almost no contact with real minority ethnic people believed that they knew a great deal about them: they knew they "took our jobs", they "caused over crowding", they "didn't accept our ways" and they "caused trouble"'(Gaine, 2005:2).
In 2002 a report produced by MORI entitled 'Attitudes towards refugees and asylum seekers: a survey of public opinion', the following findings about the attitudes of 15-18 year olds were documented:
Gain appropriately identifies that the problem for education services is that they are working with 'young people who believe they know a lot, and what they "know" is negative' (Gaine 2005:2), rather than young people who think they don't know anything.
Since 2006, Migrant Helpline and Music for Change have received increased demand to attend schools in the South East region and run programmes specifically designed to challenge negative stereotypes that exist within the schools and wider community, to tackle name calling and other potentially racist behaviour, and to encourage cohesion in classrooms that are experiencing high levels of EU Migrant pupil arrivals. EU migration is widely recognised among schools in Kent as a growing concern for teachers and parents, whilst areas such as Sussex and Surrey continue to experience high numbers of children from refugee and asylum seeking families settling in their communities. Both sources of inward migration can result in confusion, hostility and misconceptions among host communities if concerns are not properly addressed.
In light of the facts, statistics and research summarized above, good quality provision of education about asylum seekers, refugees and migration is absolutely essential for young people today. See 'Pledge 2009/10' for documentation of a model developed by Music for Change to deliver a programme to educate young people about issues of immigration, asylum seekers and refugees. Also see the 'Outcomes' section for evidence of the impact that this project has had and the 'Tips' section for suggestions of how to use some of the techniques that Music for Change use to deliver a project like this yourself.
The concept behind the Pledge project is simple:
Music for Change is a cultural music organization that has over 10 years experience of working through music and performance in a wide variety of educational environments to raise awareness and understanding about diverse cultures. Music for Change co-developed and managed the Pledge project as well as providing artists to work on the project.
Shepway Find Your Talent involves young people as beneficiaries, advocates and guides in imagining and making creative change. Working with cultural agencies, schools and youth organisations, Find Your Talent engages children and young people in the Shepway district in cultural activities. Find Your Talent co-developed the Pledge project and provided artists to work on the project.
Migrant Helpline works in schools and colleges to build understanding, to help dispel misconceptions and to encourage young people to explore their opinions in a non-judgmental environment. Migrant Helpline trained the artists for the project and ran educational sessions each of the schools we worked in.
The pledge project 2009/10 consisted of a KS3 class from four schools working with a pair of practitioners over a series of four workshops.
Each class started their project with an additional 'Fact and Fiction' session led by Migrant Helpline, which was also delivered to the practitioners as part of their training to deliver the project. Some of the topics covered in this session, which continued into the rest of the project include:
Harvey Grammar School
Pent Valley Technology College
The Marsh Academy
Highview Special School
In order to run project that exemplified the values of collaboration and partnership working and to allow the young people to access a range of creative experiences, each school worked with two different practitioners who work with different art forms. Before the project began in schools, the practitioners attended two training days in order that they could:
The practitioners were also encouraged to explore being flexible with their art form, finding links between theirs and their partners, in order to be able to respond to the creative impulses, desires and talents of the young people.
Alexander D.Great has worked as a professional musician, composer and musical arranger for more than 30 years. He is a Calypso song writer and performer and since February 2000 he has also been Calypsonian-in-Residence for the BBC. A Music for Change practitioner
Matt Rowe is a 3-D visual artist from Folkestone. A Shepway Find Your Talent practitioner.
Téa Hodzic (from Sarajevo, Bosnia) is a singer, guitarist and songwriter, specializing in Southern European music, as well as a committed educator. A Music for Change practitioner.
Patsy Burrows is a Folkestone based textile artist who specializes in creating clothing and costumes. A Shepway Find Your Talent practitioner.
Kev and Dan are a duo of musicians that run 'a song in a day' workshops in schools, working with young people to compose their own songs. Music for Change practitioners
Nicholette Goff is a 2-D visual artist that takes her inspiration from nature, using natural materials. A Shepway Find Your Talent practitioner.
H Patten is a dancer, percussionist, choreographer, filmmaker, visual artist, storyteller and performer, whose art form originates from West Africa and the Carribean. A Music for Change practitioner.
Dan Evans is a dancer and choreographer that specializes in contemporary dance. He is also experienced in running dance workshops. A Find Your Talent practitioner.
The approach that was taken in this project was one of exploration and discussion. This project aimed to value the process of learning, discovery and creative expression over the production of an end project.
The practitioners were encouraged to forget their personal art forms when working with the young people and to be open to the creative direction in which they wanted to go. This was further helped by the practitioners working in pairs as it opened up another avenue of creative exploration by finding links between two seemingly separate art forms.
It was important that the project started off with an educational session from Migrant Helpline, who are experts in working with young people on the issues of asylum seekers and refugees. In order to enter into a debate, explore their views and opinions and make informed pledges, the young people needed to be armed with the facts, rather than simply what they had assumed or heard from the media, their peers and their family.
Due to the first session being conducted by Migrant Helpline, the subsequent four workshops led by the practitioners were open platforms from which to explore these issues and work creatively.
The project was consciously process-based and client-led, meaning that the practitioners would respond to the participants and their creativity, ideas, needs and wishes. The project was interested in the participant's journey through the project, so that deeper learning and engagement could take place. The project was interested in the participants generating ideas and participating in active discovery rather than rushing them through a prescribed creative process in order to make a finished product at the end.
It was, however, important that there was something for the young people to work towards, a goal to achieve and a pay-off for their efforts. Therefore an important part of the process was every school involved coming together for the showcasing event that took place at the Quarterhouse in Folkestone. Holding the event in a new, performance venue and the value (but not pressure) that was placed on the event was important in order to cultivate a sense of purpose throughout the project. It added value to the pledges that the young people were going to make and encouraged the young people to take ownership over them as they were going to make them in front of an audience of witnesses. Additionally the event enables the participants to feel that they are part of a project that is bigger than just them, that they are part of something important, something significant.
The final, yet integral part of the project was an evaluation session run in the schools by the practitioners and an independent evaluator. This took place a month after the showcasing event and was designed to find out what impact the project had had on the young people and whether they had kept their pledges. It was important to leave an appropriate amount of time between the showcasing event and the evaluation session in order for the learning to be processed by the participants and to allow them space to assess whether the pledges had had any long term impact.
Harvey Grammar School
Taking inspiration from the monsters and beasts that were depicted in the margins of medieval manuscripts, the pupils at Harvey Grammar School explored what they considered to be the marginal areas of Folkestone and who inhabited them. They identified 'go' and 'no-go' areas in Folkestone-places where they felt they belonged and didn't belong.
They then formulated a Pledge which they was composed into a song. They also created a medieval manuscript of their Pledge, which was decorated with monsters and beasts that they had designed.
Pent Valley Technology College
The students at Pent Valley Technology College started by each randomly selecting an area of the world about which they were going to work for the rest of the project. They designed and made traditional costumes from these countries as well as learning some traditional eastern European songs. They created their pledge which they turned into a song.
Marsh Academy
At the Marsh Academy, the students lived out a scenario in which the local council was demanding that half the population of Romney Marsh were to be deported. The students had to decide how to decide who should go and who should stay. Some of the students acted as reporters, documenting and commenting on the situation as it unfolded through devised scenes. The students also learnt about the history of migration through mnemonics, and created their own to help them remember it and teach it to others.
Highview School
At Highview School the pupils explored the emotions associated with issues surrounding migration, such as sadness at leaving home and fear at arriving in a new country. They used movement and dance to devise a way to express this journey of emotions. They also worked on storytelling of traditional tales that celebrate difference as well as learning some new drumming skills.
The showcasing event held at the Quarterhouse was attended by the practitioners and students from the Harvey Grammar School, Pent Valley Technology College and The Marsh Academy. Hosted by Kev and Dan, the event began with some short films entitled 'Home to Home', made by young unaccompanied asylum seekers in Canterbury (see Resources for a link to the videos on youtube). Then followed presentations of the pledges created by the pupils and the work they had done throughout the process.
Harvey Grammar School presented a power point presentation depicting the process they had undergone throughout the project and showed their pledge in the form of medieval manuscript. They also sang a song they had written about their pledge with Alex.
Pent Valley Technology College were dressed in their traditional European costumes and explained where they were from and how they made them. They also sung some traditional eastern southern European songs as well as an original composition which was their pledge.
The Marsh Academy performed a drama that they had created about the fictional scenario about half the population of Romney Marsh being deported. The drama included stricken citizens and roaming reporters. They also delivered a presentation of the history of migration which was depicted in mnemonics.
Highview Special School sadly could not make the showcasing event and so their practitioners H and Dan led the audience through a number of exercises that they had done during their process, including facial emotions and dance. H also told a traditional story which had been used at Highview school.
In addition, two practitioners also shared/performed their own pledges. The event ended with a reception, during which the young people participated in an activity which required them to talk to and find out about people who were different to them and from different schools.
Harvey Grammar School
Pledge created by Harvey Grammar School:
This is the Pledge I make today,
When darkness nears,
I promise to not run away,
Turn and face my fears,
I will travel to new places,
Meeting rich and poor,
Different people, different faces,
Darkness is no more.
Sometimes you can feel excluded,
In a place that you don't know
People think you are deluded
Everywhere you never go.
Song created by students from the Harvey Grammar School:
Chorus:
This is the Pledge I make today,
When darkness nears,
I promise to not run away,
Turn and face my fears,
I will travel to new places,
Meeting rich and poor,
Different people, different faces,
Darkness is no more.
Being first to go somewhere
Can be pretty scaring,
Neil Armstrong and Captain Cook
They were pretty daring,
Going into the unknown,
Places undiscovered.
Facing dangers all alone,
All your fears uncovered.
Chorus
Sometimes you can feel excluded,
In a place that you don't know,
People think you are deluded,
Everywhere you never go.
Life can make you feel quite sad,
In a great big city,
Even when you're feeling glad,
Your eyes are filled with pity.
Chorus
From no-where comes a basilisk,
Hunting food to eat.
In its movement sly and brisk,
The stench of rotten meat.
Misunderstanding is the fear,
Not knowing why its there,
The beasts not knowingly appear,
From the hidden lair.
Chorus
Students completing a Migrant Helpline activity: deciding which 5 items they would take when fleeing their home
Students holding up their Pledge which they had created in the style of a medieval manuscript.
Students from Harvey Grammar School singing their pledge at the showcasing event
Pent Valley
Students in their traditional costumes
Students in their traditional costumes
Students singing traditional southern eastern European songs at the showcasing event
Students and artist Tea performing
The Marsh Academy
Students from the Marsh Academy getting into character and devising their drama
A Mnemonic to symbolize the current war in the Iraq
The beginning of the drama performed by students from The Marsh Academy
A reporter commenting on the 'events' happening in Romney Marsh
A protest supporting the deportation of the natives of Romney Marsh

Highview Special School
Students at the showcasing event taking part in the emotions exercise used by H and Dan at Highview Special School
Students learning a dance which tells a traditional story (this dance move is a parrot)!
H and Dan demonstrating a 'tortoise' dance move
Everyone joining in the dancing!
An independent evaluator attended workshops in each of the schools, the showcasing event and reflection sessions. The evaluation process involved questionnaires, interviews and activities to gather qualitative and quantitative data, which are summarized below.
During the reflection of the project, the young people gave the following responses to what they had learnt about refugees, asylum seekers and migrants:
The pledges created during the project included:
When asked if their pledge made the young people feel differently about their community, responses included:
Overall, Pledge increased awareness amongst the young people and teachers who took part in the project of the issues surrounding asylum and migration, whilst also providing the opportunity for the young people to talk about issues in a creative space and to gain new skills and experiences.
The following facts, definitions and quotes are taken from 'Mobiles, money and mayhem: the facts and fibs about asylum', a publication by Refugee Action:
An Asylum Seeker is someone who:
A Refugee is someone who:
A Refused Asylum Seeker is someone who:
An Illegal Immigrant is someone who:
An Economic Migrant is someone who:
